I am not a particular fan of Jeremy Clarkson, neither do I enjoy the
sort of television programme typified by Top Gear, however I think I can
understand why he has said some of the things that have courted recent
controversy. I will explain.
First I would add that I don't think that a man in his position should
have actually said them as publicly as he did but I think it a genuine
reflection of the behaviour of a particular section of the British
population.
I am in the same sort of middle-aged, middle-class generation as
Clarkson – which may have some bearing on matters. In my general life,
particularly with my work and my family life I am conservative,
well-mannered, considerate, righteous even, and I ensure that what I say
is 'politically correct'. However, when I get together in a certain
social situation with friends in the Clarkson generation, the other side
of our personalities is exposed. I am convinced that everyone has these
sides to their personality and that most just choose never to expose
them publicly.
No subject in conversation is taboo as long as humour can be extracted.
The more shocking the better. Michael Jackson, Terry Waite, Madeleine
McCann, Mandela – no person is excluded. There is also overt racism and
sexism, even when the group is of mixed races or mixed genders; but no
one shows offence.
I have searched for a reason for this behaviour. Whether we do this as
an antidote to the anodyne world that we inhabit, or in a desire to be
liked, or just to make others laugh, or whether it is just the beer
talking, a desire to shock, or whatever, I don't know. I don't search
too hard as I don't really want to find the answer. I don't care. It's a
release mechanism. Maybe that's the answer: We just don't care.
The thing is though, it is done in an environment where we are safe in
the knowledge that we know each other and we know no offence will be
taken. The mistake that Clarkson sometimes makes is that he behaves like
this, not caring, with little thought as to his audience – but then his
job is entertaining whereas it is only a private little corner of my
world. |