08 October 2013 - Day Seven of the civil
complaint that was filed by the McCann family against Gonçalo Amaral and other defendants.
05 November 2013 - Day Eight of the civil complaint that was filed by the McCann family
against Gonçalo Amaral and other defendants.
19 November 2013 - Day Nine: No
witnesses heard this day, judge in discussions with lawyers.
27 November 2013 - Day Ten: Screening
of documentary and interview - closing arguments set for 07 January 2014
Day Seven, 08 October 2013
Tweet from UK Justice Forum, 08 October
| Tweet from UK Justice Forum Twitter
Text version of above:
Local guy sends text
to UK media thus why they end up with virtually same script.
Day Seven: Libel Trial, 08 October 2013
Text version of above:
2:31 PM - 8 Oct 13
#McCann libel trial resumes. Parents suing ex-cop
Goncalo Amaral for £1m over his book's claims they covered up her death.
4:06 PM - 8 Oct 13
#McCann asks judge for permission to give evidence
at libel trial
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
4:10 PM - 8 Oct 13
Former Portuguese police family liaison officer Ricardo Paiva tells #McCann libel trial Amaral's book was 'based
on our investigation'
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
4:11 PM - 8 Oct 13
Paiva: the book 'contains the professional and personal opinions
of Goncalo Amaral as a police officer' #McCann
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
PM - 8 Oct 13
Contrary to #McCann
claim Paiva says publication of Amaral's book did not hinder the 'flow of information' coming in to police
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
PM - 8 Oct 13
Paiva says everything in Amaral's book 'can be found in the case files'
which have been made public #McCann
4:16 PM - 8 Oct
Port police organised crime unit head Luis Neves said Amaral's conclusion Madeleine was dead was
accepted early on by parents #McCann
4:18 PM - 8 Oct
Neves: Kate driving force behind failed July 2007 search by controversial ex-Sth African cop Danie Krugel
with body-finding machine #McCann
4:27 PM - 8 Oct
Neves: Brit police suggested bringing in sniffer dogs..'not accepted lightly' due to 'cost'
and 'no experience of it in Portugal' #McCann
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
PM - 8 Oct 13
Retired cop Francisco Moita Flores said #McCann
probe was one of 'most complex and well-investigated cases' he'd seen..Amaral
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
4:29 PM - 8 Oct 13
and Tapas 7 friends should have had their phones tapped because of 'inconsistencies'
in their statements.
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
4:34 PM - 8 Oct 13
Flores says 'prophetic and dogmatic vision' behind current
SY #McCann probe. UK cops
'only putting forward the hypothesis of abduction'
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton
4:35 PM - 8 Oct 13
Judge stops lawyers on both
sides asking Amaral's former cop colleagues their conclusions on #McCann
case because 'opinions' not 'facts'
4:41 PM - 8 Oct
Judge to Paiva: 'What's new in the book that's not in the police files?' Paiva: 'Nothing'
4:43 PM - 8 Oct 13
says book cover says it contains 'exclusive revelations'..'ok so then I have to conclude this is misleading advertising',
4:59 PM - 8 Oct
Gerry and Kate #McCann and Goncalo Amaral have all now applied to the judge to give evidence at libel trial
Kate McCann asks to be heard, 08 October
|Kate McCann asks to be heard ITV News
08 October 2013
Kate McCann has asked the judge for permission
to give evidence in the family's libel case against Goncalo Amaral. The ex-police chief published a book making allegations
about Madeleine's disappearance in May 2007.
Kate McCann asks to give evidence at libel
by Emma Murphy - Europe Correspondent
4:21pm, Tue 8 Oct 2013
Kate McCann, the mother of missing Madeleine, has asked for permission to give evidence at the libel trial of the
Portuguese detective Goncalo Amoral.
Gerry McCann has already made the same request. The judge is likely
to decide on November 5th.
Photos taken outside the Palace of
Justice, 08 October 2013
Dr Gonçalo Amaral and lawyer Dr Santos
de Oliveira pictured outside the Palace of Justice earlier today. Photo: Anne Guedes
Dr Amaral and Manuel Catarino (Principal Writer
- Correio da Manhã) pose for Anne outside the Palace of Justice in Lisbon earlier today. Photo:
Kate McCann tells libel hearing she
wants to defend herself in court against 'smears' made against her by Portuguese police, 08 October 2013
|Kate McCann tells libel hearing she wants to defend
herself in court against 'smears' made against her by Portuguese police Daily Mail
By GERARD COUZENS
- Kate McCann has requested permission to defend herself in libel case
- Gerry McCann
has also expressed a wish to speak during trial
- Family is suing Goncaro Amaral over book The Truth
of the Lie
- Police chief claimed the McCanns hid Madeleine's body after she died in an accident
then faked her abduction
17:12, 8 October 2013 | UPDATED: 17:12, 8 October 2013
The tormented mother of Madeleine
McCann has said she wants to defend herself in open court for the first time against Portuguese police 'smears' over
her daughter's disappearance.
Kate McCann has asked a judge for permission to address a libel trial brought
after a controversial book suggested the McCanns may have hidden their daughter's body and staged an abduction.
The author of The Truth Of The Lie is ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral, 56, who was tasked with investigating Madeleine's
May 2007 disappearance.
Kate's husband Gerry and Mr Amaral have already applied
to speak in the Portuguese court.
Her application, revealed at the libel trial today as former police colleagues
of Mr Amaral spoke in his defence, paves the way for an emotional finale to the case.
It comes just days ahead
of a new appeal by the McCanns for information on their missing daughter on BBC's Crimewatch which will feature a reconstruction
of events in Praia da Luz on May 3 2007.
It is thought Gerry and Kate, 45, will appeal directly to a kidnapper
during the programme.
Madeleine's mother flew to Portugal for the start of the libel trial last month - but
had left it to friends and relatives to testify before Mr Amaral's side launched its defence.
Emilia Melo e Castro, referring to Kate by her maiden name as she revealed her change of heart, said: 'On October 2
Kate Healy made an application to make a statement to this court.
'The court will decide on this application
once evidence has been heard by both sides as only then will it be it able to judge on the need for and the pertinence
of this application.'
If given the go-ahead, the McCanns and Mr Amaral are expected to speak on the same
day on or after November 27 when the last hearing in the trial at Lisbon's Palace of Justice is scheduled.
Former colleagues of Mr Amaral's turned up the heat on the McCanns today by insisting nothing he wrote in his July
2008 book was new.
The book was published just three days after the McCanns had their status as suspects over
Madeleine's disappearance officially lifted.
Around 120,000 copies were sold before it was withdrawn when
the McCanns won an injunction against the ex-police chief.
Portuguese TV station TVI, also being sued by the McCanns along
with Mr Amaral's book publishers, broadcast a controversial documentary based on the book in April 2009.
family liaison officer Ricardo Paiva told the court: 'What is in the book is based on our investigation and contains
the professional and personal opinions of Goncalo Amaral as a police officer.
'Everything that is there
can be found in the case files.'
Contradicting earlier claims by the McCanns' family and friends that
Mr Amaral's book had hindered their search for their daughter by turning the Portuguese public against them, he added:
'The flow of information continued to come in regularly.
'Neither this book or any other book affected
the flow of information.'
Luis Neves, head of a national police unit tasked with investigating organised
crime, including kidnappings, said Mr Amaral's conclusion Madeleine was dead was an idea accepted early on by her parents.
He insisted Kate was the driving force behind a failed July 2007 search for Madeleine by controversial ex-south African
detective Danie Krugel, who claimed to have invented a machine which could locate a body if provided with a DNA sample.
Neves said the reservations he felt over Mr Krugel were shared by colleagues about sniffer dogs supplied by British
police which went on to smell the 'scent of death' in the McCanns' holiday apartment and place a huge question
mark over the hypothesis Madeleine was kidnapped.
The performance of the dogs was later called into question
after they also reacted to remains at Haut de la Garenne orphanage in Jersey, which were later found to be animal bones.
Mr Neves told the court: 'The McCanns convinced us we should
bring in the south African man with his equipment.
'We didn't want to place any obstacles in the way
and so the investigating officers eventually allowed it.
'It was during this part of the investigation our
British colleagues said there was a team made up of dogs and their handlers that could help us to find out where the child
could be buried.
'It was from then on that the Algarve police division decided to allow the dogs to come
and the idea of Madeleine's death began to form and things took another direction.
'I know the suggestion
of the dogs was not accepted lightly.
'We had no experience of it in Portugal and the cost was another factor.'
Retired police officer Francisco Moita Flores, now a TV commentator, described the Madeleine McCann investigation
as one of the 'most complex and well-investigated cases' he had had ever seen and called Mr Amaral 'competent.'
He insisted the Tapas Nine - the McCanns and the friends dining with them at a tapas bar near their apartment the
night Madeleine disappeared - should have had their phones tapped because of 'inconsistencies' in their statements.
Attacking the ongoing Home Office-funded Met Police investigation into Madeleine's disappearance, called Operation
Grange, he told the court: 'There's a prophetic and dogmatic vision behind it.
are only putting forward the hypothesis of abduction.'
Judge Maria Emilio Melo e Castro stopped lawyers on
both sides asking Mr Amaral's former police colleagues what they thought about his conclusions on Madeleine and her parents
in his book because they were 'opinions' and not 'facts.'
She waved the book in her hand as she demanded to know from
Ricardo Paiva: 'The back cover says it contains exclusive revelations.
'What's new in the book that's
not in the police files?'
Told by Mr Paiva, 'Nothing', she replied: 'Ok, so then I have to conclude
this is misleading advertising.'
Another defence witness, Mr Amaral's ex-number two Vitor Tavares de Almeida,
was bizarrely dismissed after being asked just one question.
The police chief, still a serving officer despite
being convicted in January of torturing a crime suspect and receiving a two and a half suspended jail sentence, has previously
claimed he believes the McCanns concealed Madeleine's body.
He was overheard on a video link muttering: 'What
am I doing here?' before being sent away after admitting he had only read the final two pages of Mr Amaral's book.
Mr Amaral denies defamation. The case continues.
Kate McCann asks to give evidence in court
during libel trial, 08 October 2013
Kate McCann asks to give evidence in court during libel trial
Emma Murphy: Europe Correspondent
8:28pm, Tue 8 Oct 2013
Kate McCann has said she wants
to defend herself in open court. Photo: John Stillwell/PA Wire
Kate McCann has said she wants to defend
herself in open court over claims made by the Portuguese police officer who led the hunt for her daughter Madeleine. If her
application is granted it will be the first time she has appeared in a court to speak about the disappearance.
McCann’s legal team requested she be allowed to testify in the libel action the family are taking against the ex-detective
who was initially in charge of the hunt for the missing three year old.
Judge Maria Emilia Melo e Castro, who is
hearing the case, referred to Kate McCann by her maiden name as she announced the application to the court, "On October
2 Kate Healy made an application to make a statement to this court,” the judge said.
"The court will
decide on this application once evidence has been heard by both sides as only then will it be it able to judge on the need
for and the pertinence of this application."
The McCanns are suing Goncalo Amaral, over his book 'The
Truth of the Lie' in which he accused them of faking their daughter's abduction to cover up her death in their Algarve
Madeleine McCann's parents
Gerry and Kate McCann have both asked the court to speak. Credit: John Stillwell/PA Wire
At the hearing
in Portugal today colleagues of Mr Amaral spoke out in his defence insisting publication of the book in no way affected the
search for Madeleine. The book was published in 2008 just three days after the McCanns had their status as 'arguidos'
or suspects over Madeleiene's disappearance officially lifted.
Former family liaison officer Ricardo Paiva
told the court: "What is in the book is based on our investigation and contains the professional and personal opinions
of Goncalo Amaral as a police officer.
"Everything that is there can be found in the case files."
Contradicting earlier claims by the McCanns' family and friends that Mr Amaral's book had hindered their search
for their daughter by turning the Portuguese public against them, he added: "The flow of information continued to come
"Neither this book or any other book affected the flow of information."
case is expected to run until late November.
McCanns bid to give libel evidence, 08 October
McCanns bid to give libel evidence The Press Association
Press Association - Gerry and
Kate McCann are seeking to give evidence at the Lisbon trial.
Kate McCann has asked to give evidence at
the Portuguese libel trial over a book by a former local police chief.
The McCanns are suing Goncalo Amaral over
claims in his book The Truth of the Lie about their daughter Madeleine's disappearance.
The couple have launched
a legal action against the former Portuguese police chief, as well as his publisher, and the makers of a documentary based
on the book.
Madeleine's father Gerry McCann is fighting to give evidence at the trial, with the judge at the
court in Lisbon yet to rule on whether he can step into the witness box.
And today the McCanns' spokesman Clarence
Mitchell confirmed that lawyer Isabel Duarte lodged an application last week for Mrs McCann to give evidence as well.
If the judge grants the application, the couple will return to Lisbon. It is thought that if they give evidence, it will
be at the end of the trial next month.
Mr Amaral has also applied to take to the witness box and is yet to hear
whether he can or not.
Last week Gerry's sister Trish Cameron told the court that the family's pain over
Madeleine's disappearance was "multiplied 100 times" by the book.
She said the youngster's parents
had been left in "purgatory" and the book and subsequent documentary had seen them "vilified" and "demonised".
The trial has previously heard how Mrs McCann had considered suicide in the aftermath of the book's publication
The McCanns say the former detective's claims in the book The Truth Of The Lie, including suggestions
that they hid their daughter's body after she died in an accident and faked an abduction, damaged the hunt for Madeleine
and exacerbated their anguish.
If successful the family stands to gain around £1 million in damages.
Kate McCann travelled to Lisbon at the start of the trial, and her husband has attended several times in the hope of being
able to give evidence at the trial, which is expected to finish hearing evidence in November.
Madeleine, who was
then nearly four, disappeared from her family's holiday apartment in Praia da Luz in the Algarve on May 3 2007 as her
parents dined at a nearby restaurant with friends.
British detectives launched a fresh investigation into the youngster's
disappearance in July this year - two years into a review of the case - and believe she could still be alive.
new BBC Crimewatch appeal is to be aired on Monday a bid to produce new witnesses.
The appeal will include a reconstruction
of the "latest, most detailed understanding" of the events around the time Madeleine went missing.
Yard has revealed a vast log of mobile phone traffic could be the key to finding out what happened to the girl.
parents have said they remain "optimistic" of finding their daughter and will not accept she is dead until they
are presented with clear evidence.
"We've always had hope," Mr McCann told ITV.
have been a number of cases over the last few years of children and young women being found after having been taken and held
for very long periods of time.
"As parents we won't accept Madeleine is dead until we see clear evidence
that that is the case."
The Metropolitan Police now has a team of six Portuguese detectives based in Faro
who are carrying out inquiries on its behalf.
The Portuguese investigation is officially closed but authorities
there are backing the Scotland Yard inquiry and officers from both countries will work together in pursuing new leads.
Madeleine: Dramatic new court claims,
08 October 2013
Dramatic new court claims Daily Express (paper
mum Kate wants to give evidence against Portuguese detectives
Gerard Couzens in Lisbon and David Pilditch
9, 2013KATE McCann is to make a dramatic bid to nail the smears which have hampered the search
for her daughter Madeleine.
Brave Kate wants to defend herself in open court to silence her tormentor,
detective Goncalo Amaral, over false claims she was involved in a cover-up, it was revealed yesterday.
GP is expected to use new evidence unearthed by Scotland Yard to kill off Portuguese police smears once and for all. British
officers are set to unveil "fresh, substantive" material during a Crimewatch TV special on the case to be screened
It comes as detectives revealed they are closerTURN TO PAGE 5
Madeleine's mum Kate McCann wants to defend herself in court over 'smears' Sunday Express
KATE MCCANN is to make a dramatic bid to nail the smears which have hampered the search for her daughter Madeleine.
By: Gerard Couzens and David Pilditch
Published: Wed, October 9, 2013
Brave Kate wants to defend herself in open court to silence
her tormentor, detective Goncalo Amaral, over false claims she was involved in a cover-up, it was revealed yesterday.
The former GP is expected to use new evidence unearthed by Scotland Yard to kill off Portuguese police smears once and for
all. British officers are set to unveil "fresh, substantive" material during a Crimewatch TV special on the case
to be screened on Monday.
It comes as detectives revealed they are closer than ever to discovering what happened
to Madeleine who disappeared during a family holiday in Portugal in 2007.
Kate and husband Gerry, 45, hope
a targeted appeal will lead to a significant breakthrough.
And the information could shatter the claims made against
Madeleine's parents by the former police chief.
Now Kate has asked a judge for permission to address a £1million
libel trial in Lisbon. Heart consultant Gerry had already asked permission to address the hearing as has Mr Amaral.
Kate's application – revealed at the restart of the
hearing yesterday – paves the way for an emotion-charged finale.
If given the go-ahead, the McCanns and Mr
Amaral are expected to speak on the same day on or after November 27 when the last hearing in the trial at Lisbon’s
Palace of Justice is scheduled.
Madeleine's parents are convinced their daughter was abducted and insist there
is no evidence to suggest she is no longer alive. She would now be 10.
Kate and Gerry are suing Mr Amaral over
allegations in his book The Truth Of The Lie.
And in a day of dramatic developments, former Portuguese colleagues
yesterday told the hearing that nothing Mr Amaral wrote in the book was new.
Former family liaison officer Ricardo
Paiva told the court: "What is in the book is based on our investigation and contains the professional and personal opinions
of Goncalo Amaral as a police officer.
"Everything that is there can be found in the case files."
Mr Paiva insisted the book's publication did not damage the search
for Madeleine. He said: "The flow of information continued to come in regularly. Neither this book or any other book
affected the flow."
Luis Neves, head of a national police unit tasked with investigating organised crime including
kidnappings, told the court it was British police who began developing the theory Madeleine had died.
dogs brought in by an officer from the UK were said to have put a huge question mark over the theory that Madeleine was kidnapped.
He said: "Our British colleagues said there was a team made up of dogs and their handlers that could help us
to find out where the child could be buried.
"It was from then on that the Algarve police division decided
to allow the dogs to come and the idea of Madeleine's death began to form and things took another direction. I know the
suggestion of the dogs was not accepted lightly. We had no experience of it in Portugal and the cost was another factor."
But retired police officer Francisco Moita Flores, now a TV commentator, attacked the on-going Metropolitan Police
investigation for assuming that Madeleine is dead.
"There's a prophetic and dogmatic vision behind it,"
he said. He described the Portuguese investigation as one of the "most complex and well-investigated cases" he had
ever seen and called Mr Amaral "competent".
Kate flew to Portugal for the start of the libel trial last
month. But so far she has left it to friends and relatives to testify on behalf of the couple.
Maria Emilia Melo e Castro, referring to her request to make a statement, said: "The court will decide on this application
once evidence has been heard by both sides as only then will I be able to judge on the need for and the pertinence of this
Around 120,000 copies of the book were sold before it was withdrawn when the McCanns won an
injunction against the ex-police chief.
Portuguese TV station TVI is also being sued over a documentary based on
the book. Mr Amaral, 56, denies defamation. The hearing was adjourned until November 5.
The following line in this article is incorrect:
'But retired police officer Francisco Moita Flores,
now a TV commentator, attacked the on-going Metropolitan Police investigation
for assuming that Madeleine is dead.'
It should read:
'But retired police officer Francisco
Moita Flores, now a TV commentator, attacked the on-going Metropolitan Police
investigation for assuming that Madeleine is kidnapped.'
The paper edition carries the correct version.
Maddy mum agony: I'll tell all in
court, 09 October 2013
mum agony: I'll tell all in court Daily Mirror (paper edition)
By Martin Fricker
Wednesday, 09 October 2013KATE McCann wants
to defend herself in court over heartbreaking smears.
The mum, 45, has applied to give evidence in a libel
trial in Portugal against a former police chief who suggested Kate's daughter Madeleine died in an accident and her parents
tried to cover it up.
A source said Kate wants the former officer to "see the pain he caused".FULL STORY: PAGE 4
Madeleine McCann: Mum Kate wants to give evidence
in libel trial against ex-cop
By Martin Fricker | 9 Oct 2013 00:27The
McCann family is suing Goncalo Amaral over claims he made in his book about the case - including alleging they had hidden
Struggling to cope after the disappearance of her daughter Madeleine,
Kate McCann was horrified by lurid claims made in a book by a former police chief.
It said Madeleine had
died in an accident which her parents then covered up before hiding her body.
Yesterday it emerged that Kate,
45, now wants to appear in court to confront former Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral who wrote the book, and to tell
him the emotional trauma that it caused.
The mum, who has asked for permission to give evidence in the £1million
libel trial against the ex-officer, hopes giving an emotional account will help her and husband Gerry win the court case.
A source close to the couple said: "Kate is desperate to show the court just how much hurt the book and Mr Amaral
"Kate and Gerry feel the search for Madeleine was hampered by the false claims made in the book.
"The claims caused a great deal of distress to them both. That's what Kate wants to tell the court.
"She wants to look Mr Amaral in the eye so he can see the pain he caused to her and her family."
sight of ex-GP Kate revealing what she felt about the book would bring the trial in Portugal's capital Lisbon to a remarkable
It had already emerged that Gerry, also 45, had asked to be a witness during the case at the Palace
Kate's formal bid to give a statement in open court was revealed yesterday at the restart of the
libel trial which should come to an end next month.
It emerged that she made the application on October 2. If judge
Maria Emilia Melo e Castro approves the request, it is possible Kate could address the court on the same day as Mr Amaral.
His book was published in 2008 three days after the McCanns had their status as arguidos – formal suspects
Madeleine was just three when she vanished from the family's holiday apartment in the Portuguese
resort of Praia da Luz in May 2007. Kate and Gerry were dining with friends at a nearby restaurant at the time she disappeared.
The claims in Mr Amaral's book, called The Truth of the Lie, left the parents heartbroken. The McCanns, of Rothley,
Leics, are suing Mr Amaral – who also suggested the couple cashed in on £2million of public donations –
the publishers and a TV channel.
Around 120,000 copies of the book were sold before it was withdrawn when the
McCanns were granted an injunction against him.
Mr Amaral, 56, insisted everything in his book was already contained
in police and court case files which had been made public.
Ex-colleagues have told the court the book did not
hinder the search. Officers from Operation Grange – the Met police probe into the disappearance – said this
week that arrests could be imminent.
It came as it emerged that on BBC's Crimewatch show on Monday, Kate and
Gerry will launch a new appeal for information on their missing daughter.
Maddie - Mum begs court: Let me clear
my name, 09 October 2013
Maddie - Mum begs court: Let me clear my name Daily Star (paper edition)
ANGRY Kate McCann wants to defend herself in court against Portuguese
police "smears" that she covered up the death of her daughter Madeleine, right.
She has asked a judge
for permission to peak at her family's £1m libel hearing.
Full story: Page 7
Maddie mum begs court: Let me clear my name
FURIOUS Kate McCann wants to defend herself in court against Portuguese police "smears" that she covered up
daughter Madeleine's death.
By Jerry Lawton
/ Published 9th October 2013
She has asked a judge for permission to address her family's
£1million libel hearing against former police chief Goncalo Amaral over his book The Truth Of The Lie.
it he accused Kate and husband Gerry, both 45, of faking their daughter's abduction to cover up her death in their Algarve
holiday flat in 2007.
Kate's bid to give evidence was revealed yesterday as Mr Amaral's former police colleagues
spoke in his defence at the court in Lisbon, Portugal.
Luis Neves, head of a national police unit, said Mr Amaral's
conclusion Madeleine was dead was accepted by her parents.
He said Kate was the driving force behind a search by
ex-South African detective Danie Krugel, who said he had a machine that could find a body.
Police also had doubts
about sniffer dogs from Britain.
"The McCanns convinced us we should bring in the South
African man with his equipment," Mr Neves said.
"We didn't want to place any obstacles in the way
so the investigating officers allowed it.
"During this part of the investigation our British colleagues said
there was a team made up of dogs and their handlers that could help us.
"The Algarve police decided to allow
the dogs to come and the idea of Madeleine's death began to form."
Retired officer Francisco Moita Flores
said the new probe by the Metropolitan Police was based only on "the hypothesis of abduction". The original probe
was one of the "most complex and well-investigated cases" he had seen.
He said the Mc-Canns and pals
should have had their phones tapped because of "inconsistencies" in statements they made.
56, denies defamation. The case continues.
Daily Star, paper edition: 'I must
defend myself against Maddie cops' smears says mother', 09 October 2013
[text of article same as that online]
Gonçalo Amaral's book may have
"misleading advertising", said the Judge, 09 October 2013
Gonçalo Amaral's book may have "misleading
advertising", said the Judge Diário de Notícias (paper
edition, page 19)
Trial - PJ Director admitted
that initial thesis of Maddie's abduction was rushed
Wednesday, 9 October 2013
With thanks to Astro/Joana for translation
The Judge at the 1st Civil Court of Lisbon who is presiding the
McCann couple's lawsuit against the former PJ inspector - who defends the thesis of the parents' responsibility in
their daughter Madeleine's death - suggested that Gonçalo Amaral's book may have "misleading advertising",
because contrary to what is announced on its back cover it does not contain "unique revelations" about the case
of the disappearance of the little girl in 2007, in Praia da Luz.
The magistrate's conclusion followed the
statements of one of Amaral's defence witnesses that was heard in court yesterday, the PJ inspector Ricardo Paiva, who
took part in the investigative team. He stated that 'The Truth of the Lie' did not contain any more information than
what was in the files of the process that has been shelved in the mean time, and made public. Thus Gonçalo Amaral's
defence seeks to devalue the impact of the accusations that are contained in the book on the McCann family and to empty the
arguments that sustain Gerry and Kate McCann's request for 1.2 million as compensation over moral damages.
are the 'revelations' in the book?" the judge asked Ricardo Paiva. "There is nothing new compared with the
inquiry," the inspector replied. "But it says the contrary on the back cover, it says that there are 'unique
revelations'. What are those?" the magistrate insisted. "They may be unique to those who bought the book and
didn't read the case files," Ricardo Paiva suggested. Ironically, the judge concluded "Then it's misleading
The McCann couple's lawyers, on the other hand, have been trying to demonstrate that the
book contains a lot more information than the criminal process, namely the author's final conclusion that the little girl
died in the apartment, which is the motive of the moral damage that was caused to the family.
session, the director of the National Counter-Terrorism Unit (UNCT) testified for Gonçalo Amaral's defence and
implied that the abduction theory, with which the investigation started right after the little girl's disappearance, may
have been rushed. "When Dr Guilhermino Encarnação [former PJ director] held the first press conference
and spoke about an abduction, we still didn't know whether it was one thing or another," he said. According to Luís
Neves, an abduction expert, at the time, the signs that usually support this type of crime, like "a ransom note",
were missing. The director of UNCT also recalled that it was Maddie's parents who, being first to admit that their daughter
might be dead, ended up indirectly triggering the arrival in Portugal of the English dogs that detected cadaver odour in the
apartment where Maddie disappeared from. And that was when Amaral's thesis started to gain strength.
SIC guarantees that they were not approached
television network and media company, which runs several television channels] was not approached to broadcast BBC's Crimewatch
programme on the "Maddie case", contrary to what the English press published. Next Monday, on 14 October, the English
TV channel, BBC, that broadcasts Crimewatch, promises to show a reconstruction of Madeleine McCann's disappearance. The
script is a result of Scotland Yard's investigation. The British press assured that Portuguese TV channels refused to
broadcast it, however when questioned by DN, an official source from SIC guaranteed that they were never contacted. RTP and
TVI did not reply up to the closure of this edition.
Gonçalo Amaral's book did not
add "anything new", 10 October 2013
|Gonçalo Amaral's book did not add "anything
new" Jornal de Notícias (paper edition, page 10)
09 October 2013
With thanks to
Joana Morais for translation
Two members of the Judiciary Police have stated yesterday in court,
that Gonçalo Amaral's book did not add anything new to what was already known regarding the process of the investigation
of the English child, who disappeared in the Algarve, in May 2007. The statements of these two witnesses, Luís Neves
and Ricardo Paiva, concur with Gonçalo Amaral's defence argument, which alleges that the book written by the former
coordinator of the Judiciary Police "contained nothing new, nothing that it wasn't published before".
Gonçalo Amaral is being tried at Lisbon's Civil Court after a complaint from the McCanns, who claim the book
"has deeply affected the family" and seek 1.2 million euros for alleged defamation. Inspector Ricardo Paiva, who
was directly involved in the investigation, considered that the book did not add "anything new".
Neves, who coordinated part of the investigation and was the then director of the Judiciary Police Organized Crime Unit, stated
the same. The judge ended up by ironically saying that the book had "misleading advertising", since the cover promised
"revelations" about the case.
McCanns could face court over report, 29
McCanns could face court over report Irish Daily Mail (paper edition, page 8)
By Gerard Couzens
29 October 2013
THE parents of Madeleine McCann faced further pressure
yesterday after ex-police chief Goncalo Amaral hinted he may fight them in court over a key report they allegedly held back.
Gerry and Kate McCann were accused at the weekend of sidelining the 2008 report by former MI5 investigators they hired
after it pinpointed 'anomalies' in statements they and their friends made.
The result was that e-fits of
the prime suspect in Madeleine McCann's abduction – hidden for five years in the unpublished report – were
only made public this month during a new Met Police appeal.
The report said Irish holidaymaker Martin Smith's
sighting of a man carrying a girl in pyjamas near the McCann's Algarve holiday apartment was 'credible evidence'
which had been 'neglected for too long.'
Mr Amaral's lawyer said last night he was considering raising
the issue in the couple's ongoing libel trial against the former police chief.
The McCanns are seeking one
million pounds in damages over the ex-detective's claims in his July 2008 book The Truth of the Lie that they faked their
daughter's abduction to cover up her death in their holiday flat.
Vitor Santos de Oliveira, who is representing
Mr Amaral, said: 'We are aware of the revelations concerning this report by the McCanns' former investigators and
believe they are very important.
'It is possible I may try to submit it as evidence to defend my client but
I haven't decided yet.
'Nothing's been ruled out. We are analysing the relevance of the report and
considering our position. We have no intention of introducing irrelevant material into this case because we respect the McCanns
as people and have no intention of harming them for sake of it,' he said.
'But I can tell you that if we
feel something is relevant in disproving the McCanns' claims about my client then we will have no hesitation in using
'I think the revelations about the suppression of this report are very important with regards to the ongoing
'It's a report written by McCann-hired investigators who make strong criticisms of the couple.
'As far as the civil libel case is going we are very calm,' Mr de Oliveira continued.
arguments in his book have been backed up in court by his former police colleagues who say it was the police position in 2008
when the book was published.'
The ongoing libel case launched by the McCanns against Mr Amaral is due to restart
Day Eight, 05 November 2013
Gonçalo Amaral and Dr Santos
de Oliveira outside the Palace of Justice in Lisbon, 05 November 2013
Libel Trial: Day 8 tweets, 05 November
Libel Trial: Day 8 tweets UK Justice Forum
Text version of above:
8:42 AM - 5 Nov
Today in Lisbon, witnesses Paulo Sargento, Valentim de Carvalho, Luis Varela Marreiros, Mario Lopes,
Tania Raposo, Antonio Paulo dos Santos.
UK Justice Forum@Justice_Forum
1:00 PM - 5 Nov 13
Day 8 of the #McCann vs
Gonçalo #Amaral libel case and yet
more absent witnesses. Amaral book 'Truth of the Lie' editor on the stand earlier
UK Justice Forum@Justice_Forum
1:39 PM - 5 Nov 13
Paulo Sargento unable to take stand at #McCann
vs #Amaral libel trial
today as he is on his honeymoon. Will do so on 27th.
UK Justice Forum@Justice_Forum
1:50 PM - 5 Nov 13
#McCann vs Goncalo #Amaral libel trial gets going again in Lisbon with witnesses from Portuguese
TVI and other media.
UK Justice Forum@Justice_Forum
7:27 PM - 5 Nov 13
#McCann vs #Amaral libel
case 3 witnesses today. Mario Sena Lopes, the editor of G&P and this afternoon Antonio dos Santos and Luis Froes.
UK Justice Forum@Justice_Forum
7:31 PM - 5 Nov 13
#McCann vs #Amaral libel
trial. Luis Froes, manager of Valentim de Carvalhos Filmes, was told to return on the 27th to answer questions.
Police chief blamed Kate and Gerry McCann
for Madeleine's disappearance 'to ensure Portuguese detectives didn't abandon case', 05 November 2013
|Police chief blamed Kate and Gerry McCann for Madeleine's
disappearance 'to ensure Portuguese detectives didn't abandon case' Daily Mail
By GERARD COUZENS
- Goncalo Amaral was said to have been 'against shelving of original probe'
- Kate and Gerry McCann are suing Mr Amaral over his claims in 2008 book
- He alleged couple faked the abduction to cover up her death in Portugal
- McCanns say book turned people against them when they needed help
PUBLISHED: 20:24, 5 November 2013 | UPDATED: 20:24,
5 November 2013
A former Portuguese police chief blamed Madeleine McCann's parents for the three-year-old
girl's disappearance to ensure detectives carried on looking for her, a former colleague claimed today.
Paulo dos Santos told a Lisbon court he believed his friend Goncalo Amaral penned a book pointing the finger at the couple
because he was against the shelving of the original investigation.
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing Mr Amaral over
his claims in his July 2008 book The Truth of the Lie that they faked their daughter's abduction to cover up her death
in their holiday apartment.
Trial: Kate and Gerry McCann (right)
are suing former Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral (left) over his claims in a book that they faked their daughter's
abduction to cover up her death in their holiday apartment
His book was released three days after
the Portuguese police probe into the girl's disappearance was archived and the McCanns were told their status as official
suspects or arguidos was being lifted.
Defence witness Mr dos Santos, who worked with Mr Amaral in the early Nineties
and remains in close contact with him, spoke at the hearing this afternoon.
He said: 'Everything that's
in the book appears to be in the case files. It's not fictional. They are the conclusions of a factual analysis by Goncalo
Amaral as the head of the police investigation.
'I think the main reason he wrote the book was so that the
case would continue to be investigated. When he published the book I presume he didn't agree with its archiving.'
Today's libel trial hearing was the first since Portuguese authorities announced last month they were reopening
their probe into Madeleine's disappearance more than five years after it was shelved.
The morning court session
started with a disappointment for the defence when it emerged a key witness was on honeymoon and his evidence had to be rescheduled
for a later date.
Publication: Mr Amaral's 2008
book was released three days after the Portuguese police probe into the girl's disappearance was archived and the McCanns
were told their status as official suspects was being lifted
Criminologist and university professor
Paulo Sargento was expected to support Mr Amaral and say he did not believe Madeleine had been abducted from her Algarve holiday
In October 2007 he created a 3D reconstruction of the night on May 3, 2007 when Madeleine disappeared
- and concluded any abductor would only have had eight minutes in which to strike.
He later came up with a computer edit based on witness statements
of a long-haired bearded man which the McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell insisted at the time could cause confusion.
Mario Sena Lopes, editor of Guerra & Paz which published Mr Amaral's controversial book, admitted he could
not guarantee all copies had been returned after the McCanns successfully injected it.
The couple secured a temporary
injunction in September 2008 before a court upheld the ban in February 2010 after a challenge from Mr Amaral. The injunction
was lifted again in March 2011.
Mr Lopes, who is still Mr Amaral's literary agent, told the hearing: 'There
are always booksellers who do not respect the orders of the distributors.'
He also admitted knowing the book
had been circulated in Brazil but insisted Guerra & Paz had nothing to do with it.
Luis Vale Frois, former
managing director of a firm which distributed a DVD of a documentary based on Mr Amaral's book, said it was inevitable
pirate copies would find their way onto the Internet.
He told the hearing: 'If this week you release a series
on TV, next week it's already on the internet with Portuguese subtitles.'
Concern: Kate and Gerry McCann
claim Mr Amaral's book turned Portuguese people against them when they most needed their help in finding their daughter
Mr Amaral, removed as head of the Madeleine McCann probe in October 2007 after criticising the British police, attended
court for the trial as he has done every day since its start in September.
ANGER AT MONTEIRO REPORTS
Portuguese-based Cape Verdean associations have reacted angrily
to reports an immigrant thief has been blamed for Madeleine McCann's disappearance and death.
It emerged last
week Euclides Monteiro, who died in a tractor accident in 2009, was a suspect.
A spokesman for a Cape Verdean association
said: 'The representatives of Cape Verdean associations in Portugal always defend the normal workings of justice and the
idea that unlawful behaviour should be punished accordingly through the proper legal channels.
denounce the fact that this immigrant cannot defend himself from these accusations in the Madeleine McCann case which could,
conveniently, remove blame from other people and ease some consciences.
'We discover history repeating itself
- with yet another Cape Verdian suspect and a community which feels once again smeared.'
He has been critical of a new British police appeal about the
six-and-a-half year-old mystery, branding it a 'PR campaign of intoxication and misinformation.'
declined to comment today on the reopened Portuguese police investigation into Madeleine's disappearance.
Amaral's lawyer Vitor dos Santos insisted outside court: 'We are not going to make any comment about the criminal
investigation. This is a civil case and when it's over my client will be free to speak. No lawyer should make any statements
about people being absolved or not being absolved from an investigation.
'This is not the time to be saying
anything about it because it makes no sense to do so.'
The McCanns claim Mr Amaral's book turned Portuguese
people against them when they most needed their help in finding their daughter.
The ex-police chief is denying
defamation and insists everything in the book was contained in police files. Former police colleagues have given evidence
backing his argument.
The McCanns, of Rothley, Leicestershire, have applied to take the witness stand as well as
Judge Maria Emilia Melo e Castro is expected to rule on their application at the end of the month. The
case, scheduled to finish in December, continues.
Maddie cop on 'side of parents',
06 November 2013
Maddie cop on 'side of parents' Daily
Star (paper edition, page 5)
by JERRY LAWTON
Wednesday, November 6, 2013
The former police chief who wrote a book accusing Madeleine McCann's parents
of covering up her death was trying to encourage officers to keep looking for her.
Goncalo Amaral shared the desire
of Madeleine's parents to keep the case open, a court was told.
That was the reason he penned his controversial
best seller about the case, former police colleague Antonio Paulo dos Santos told a Lisbon court.
Amaral wrote his 2008 book The Truth Of The Lie because he opposed the Portuguese police decision to shelve the case.
He said: "Everything that's in the book appears to be in the case files. It's not fictional."
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing Mr Amaral for £1million over his claims they faked their daughter's abduction
to cover up her death in their holiday flat.
Mr Amaral's book was released three days after the Portuguese
police investigation into the youngster's disappearance was shelved.
The hearing continues.
Day Nine: Lawyers meeting (no witnesses
heard), 19 November 2013
Libel trial McCann v Gonçalo
Amaral - Day 9, 19 November 2013
Libel trial McCann v Gonçalo Amaral - Day 9
UK Justice Forum
With thanks to Anne Guedes
Libel Trial > McCann v Gonçalo Amaral - Day 9
Lisbon - Tuesday
19 Nov 2013
All lawyers are present. VCFilmes/Multimedia's lawyer is substituted by a lawyer who states that
she took part in the Providência Cautelar (Injunction hearing). Witnesses due to testify today are dismissed by
defendants TVI, VC and Gonçalo Amaral and will no longer be required to give evidence.
The Judge starts
the session by raising the issue of documents requested by the plaintiffs evidencing the value of royalties paid to Gonçalo
Amaral. She reminds the Court that G&P's position is that the request is extemporaneous and illegal and that no other
payment was received beyond that previously declared to the Court. One such document relates to a request to Gonçalo
Amaral to provide receipts X and Y specific to the period from 17 - 30 October 2008 and from 6 - 30 November 2009. The Judge
adds that any others are of no consequence since G&P has proven that no other royalties were paid to Gonçalo Amaral.
The Judge reminds the Court of the principle that when a Party declares to another Party that a requested document
does not exist or is not in their possession, the legal remedy is not for the pursuer to make a further request but to prove
through whatever means that the respondent is being untruthful. The Judge therefore grants a request by the plaintiffs
that receipts be provided as previously requested since the defender has failed to produce the information sought.
TVI must provide an extract of accounts for the fiscal years 2008, 2009 and 2010 related to VCFilmes and VCMultimédia.
They are given 10 days to produce the relevant documents.
The Judge omits partially a request concerning the accounts
of VCFilmes, which are limited to the period from the 7 February 2012 onwards. VCFilmes is also given 10 days to produce the
The Judge reminds the Court that the request by the plaintiffs is related to the search of material
facts in order that justice is done. However, she adds that the lawyer representing G&P should consider that if any of
the documents requested in the process contain information unrelated to Gonçalo Amaral then that should be maintained
apart for commercial and/or fiscal reasons. The defence is therefore authorised to present said documents in the judicial
section in order to protect any commercially sensitive information, making only available that which relates to the process
concerning the relationship between G&P and Gonçalo Amaral. G&P is given 10 days to respond to the request.
The Judge adds that G&P has already provided indications about the financial aspect of the publication of the
book and about the number of books that have been sold.
The Judge finally confirms that the date of the next hearing
will be on Wednesday 27 November 2013. The date for the final allegations will then be fixed.End of session.
Disgraced Madeleine McCann detective must
reveal how much money he made from book about bungled Maddie probe, 20 November 2013
Disgraced Madeleine McCann detective must reveal how much
money he made from book about bungled Maddie probe Daily Mirror
By Andy Lines | 20 Nov 2013 00:00
judge ordered Goncalo Amaral to hand over receipts - Gerry and KateMcCann are suing him for £1million over his book
The Truth of the Lie
Disgraced former detective Goncalo Amaral was yesterday ordered
by a judge in Lisbon to reveal how much cash he made from a book about the bungled Madeleine McCann probe.
56, has 10 days to hand over receipts.
The book's publishers and the producers of a TV documentary were also
instructed to reveal how much they paid him in royalties.
Gerry and Kate, both 45, are suing him for £1million
over his book The Truth of the Lie, in which he claimed they covered up their girl's death in the Algarve in 2007.
He denies defamation.
Maddie cop order Daily
Mirror (paper edition, page 19)
[text as per online article]
Court Orders Madeleine McCann Detective Concalo
Amaral to Reveal Earnings from Conspiracy Book, 20 November 2013
Court Orders Madeleine McCann Detective Concalo Amaral to
Reveal Earnings from Conspiracy Book International Business Times
By DOMINIC GOVER | November 20, 2013 11:05 AM GMT
A judge in Lisbon has ordered Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral
to reveal how much he earned from a book he wrote, claiming Madeleine McCann was dead and her parents were to blame.
Concalo Amaral must hand over receipts showing how much he raked in from sales of his 2008 book The Truth of the Lie.
The order was made during Amaral's trial for libel. Kate and Jerry McCann are suing him for £1m over defamatory
claims against them.
The producers of a TV documentary must also reveal how much Amaral, 56, was paid to take part
in it, the court ruled.
The Truth of the Lie remains unpublished in Britain because of its explosive allegations,
which led to Amaral being discredited as a reliable source of insight about events surrounding McCann's disappearance.
It was released only three days after Kate and Jerry were dropped as suspects in the disappearence of Madeleine, one
year after Madeleine vanished in 2007.
Former police chief Amaral claimed in his book that that Madeleine died
in the apartment block in Praia da Luz and that her parents constructed the disappearance narrative to cover it up.
He denies defamation.
Day Ten: Screening of documentary and
interview, 27 November 2013
Judge postpones decision on Plaintiff
statements until 7 January 2014, 27 November 2013
[text version of above]
17:05 AM - 27 Nov 2013
Day 10 of the #McCann
Family v Gonçalo #Amaral & Others
libel trial. Witness Paulo Sargento dismissed by court and will no longer testify.
UK Justice Forum @Justice_forum
17:07 AM - 27 Nov 2013
Day 10 of the #McCann Family
v Gonçalo #Amaral & Others libel
trial. Judge postpones decision on Plaintiff statements until 7 January 2014.
Portugal court sets 2014 hearing in Maddie
libel case, 27 November 2013
|Portugal court sets 2014 hearing in Maddie libel case Global Post
Agence France-Presse | November 27, 2013 12:47
A Portuguese judge
on Wednesday delayed until early 2014 the final hearing in a libel case brought by the parents of missing Madeleine McCann.
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing Goncalo Amaral, the former lead detective in the hunt for Madeleine, after she vanished
from their Portugal holiday apartment in May 2007.
The couple were staying in the southern Algarve resort of Praia
da Luz when their daughter, just days shy of her fourth birthday, went missing from her bedroom as they dined at a nearby
Judge Maria Emilia Melo e Castro set January 7 as the date for final hearings or possible testimony
by Madeleine's parents and Amaral. The court will rule on whether it will hear testimony by the two parties before that
date, she said.
Amaral, who led the Portuguese police investigation, wrote a book advancing the theory that Madeleine
died accidentally and that her parents were implicated in her death.
The family is seeking the equivalent of £1
million (1.2 million euros, $1.6 million) in damages.
Kate and Gerry McCann have argued that the book impeded the
search for their daughter.
On Wednesday morning, the court heard the final witness in the case and watched a documentary
adapted from Amaral's book.
Portuguese authorities said last month they were reopening their probe into the
disappearance of Madeleine.
Portuguese authorities closed their investigation into her disappearance in 2008, but
Scotland Yard spent two years reviewing it at the British government's request and opened their own probe in July this
The McCanns have led a six-year campaign to find Madeleine, who they believe was kidnapped and is still alive.
Closing arguments not until 2014, 27
|Closing arguments not until 2014 Nova Gente
27 November 2013, 18h08m
The closing arguments in the case that the parents of Maddie
McCann have brought against Gonçalo Amaral will not be heard until the month of January next year.
was held, in the 1st Civil Court of Lisbon, the hearing of the defamation lawsuit that Kate and Gerry McCann have brought
against the former judicial police inspector Gonçalo Amaral.
The video reconstruction of the disappearance
of Madeleine McCann - based on the first six months of the investigation - and an interview with Gonçalo Amaral by
Julia Pinheiro, from the morning programme on SIC, were screened by the court.
At the next hearing, scheduled for
January 7, 2014, and in accordance with the judge, any statements of the parties will be heard - McCann and Amaral - should
they be allowed, and closing arguments.
Due to the impossibility of fixing a suitable time between the defense
and the prosecution it was not possible to schedule the arguments, and the final trial session for the parties, to an
Closing arguments in Amaral libel case
set for January, 05 November 2013
|Closing arguments in Amaral libel case set for January
The Portugal News
BY BRENDAN BEER · 05-12-2013 15:04:00
arguments in the libel case against the former Portuguese police detective Gonçalo Amaral instituted by parents of
Madeleine McCann have been set for 7 January by a Lisbon high court.
The Lisbon Civil Court revealed that the final allegations by
the legal team representing Kate and Gerry McCann will start at 9.30am.
In this civil case, the McCanns are demanding
compensation of 1.2 million euros from Amaral who was the lead investigator for the first six months into the case of the
disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
In his book, 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie', Amaral defended the theory
that Kate and Gerry McCann could be guilty of concealing a body.
Running parallel to the libel case is an injunction
by the McCanns stopping Amaral from selling his book and a DVD which was aired on Portuguese television channel TVI.
The injunction came to force in January 2010, when a Lisbon court ruled the book and video could not be circulated in Portugal.
The decision was later overturned by a Lisbon Appeal Court, but following a counter claim by the McCanns, the Supreme
Justice Tribunal upheld the earlier verdict against Amaral.
Madeleine McCann has been missing since the night of
3 May 2007. The investigation into her disappearance was shelved in July 2008 due to a lack of evidence, but re-opened this
year on 24 October by the Portuguese Attorney-General's Office.
In a statement sent to The Portugal News, the
Attorney-General explained: "The Public Prosecutor's Office has determined the re-opening of the inquiry relating
to the disappearance of Madeleine McCann following a proposal by the Polícia Judiciária and due to the presentation
of new elements which justify the continuation of the investigation."
Portuguese police, while conducting
a separate investigation, have also been asked to assist Scotland Yard in following up separate lines of inquiry.
The controversial book which runs over 200 pages, was released shortly after the case was closed in 2008 and also saw the
former chief inspector resign permanently from the police force that year to, as he put it, unveil the "facts of the
Speaking to The Portugal News shortly after releasing his book, Gonçalo Amaral lamented
the fact that the case had been closed.
"We should have continued investigating the parents in order to either
charge them or rule them out as suspects", he said in the summer of 2008. "If I represented this couple, I would
have insisted that police investigations continue. Not everything we do is to incriminate a suspect. Often a phone will be
tapped in order to obtain information that will clear a suspect."
When questioned over the probability of
a lawsuit over the release of his book, he replied: "My book is based on facts. It could be a good occasion to take all
the case files to court and compare what I wrote with that which is contained in the files."
Speaking to The
Portugal News in early 2009, Gerry McCann stressed "that there is no evidence that Madeleine is dead and there is no
evidence to suggest that Kate and I were involved in any theories."
Gerry McCann also insisted they would
have been legally compelled to be available for a reconstruction due to their status as arguidos, even the motives of Portuguese
police were questionable.
"Don't get me wrong, we had major concerns as to why the reconstruction was
being done", arguing that "the police reconstruction was not aimed at finding Madeleine, but rather to look for
inconsistencies. There were 12 or 15 people involved and it is inevitable there would be inconsistencies."